|
|
 |
PT3 vs HEM |
 |
1
 |
k2o4 United States. May 14 2008 11:19. Posts 4803 | | |
So after reformatting I finally downloaded PT3 figuring I would give up HoldemManager and move onto the new and improved PT..... but after messing with it for a bit I'm not very impressed. I guess I should give it a bit more time before I write it off, but overall I've seen a lot more downsides than up. I'll list em:
Where PT is worse than HEM
1) The graph doesn't have an EV option.
2) There's no EV stats anywhere
3) Takes longer to load up stats (reports) than HEM does
4) The HUD isn't as well put together, plus HEM has better choices on the HUD.
Ok, some of my complaints went away while writing this cause I took the time to hunt around and found that they had a good list of stats and that the reason it was so slow last night is cause I was importing hands into HEM at the same time I tried to load reports in PT3.
Where PT is BETTER than HEM
1) The graph is prettier even though it doesn't have as many options.
2) It gives you a multi-table ratio for your sessions which is nice
3) The reports are all pretty good, especially in terms of giving you your winnings.
Overall they both seem to have a lot of bugs, especially in the HUDs. They both need a lot of work before I'd be overjoyed with either. But right now HEM is set up more cleanly for me. The thing that sux is that there's no way to use PokerEV or pokergrapher and so on with HEM. PT3 might not work with those either yet, but I'm sure that eventually it will since people always build tools to work off of the PT database.
Ok, that's my ramble for now. Originally I thought I'd put some serious thought into this but I got lazy.
|
| |
|
| 1
 |
The72o Zimbabwe. May 14 2008 12:54. Posts 6112 | | | |
|
| A Hard Way to Make an Easy Living | |
|
| 1
 |
Ket  United Kingdom. May 14 2008 15:43. Posts 8665 | | |
pt3 is still in its final beta and the hud issues are known... unfair to compare it right now to a completed product thats been retail for months. i'd use HEM for another 2-4 weeks before switching, when they finally make pt3 perfect it will be perfectly perfect. |
|
| 1
|
k2o4 United States. May 15 2008 11:30. Posts 4803 | | |
| | On May 14 2008 14:43 Ket wrote:
pt3 is still in its final beta and the hud issues are known... unfair to compare it right now to a completed product thats been retail for months. i'd use HEM for another 2-4 weeks before switching, when they finally make pt3 perfect it will be perfectly perfect. |
haha perfectly perfect, that sounds irresistible =)
|
| |
|
| |
|
|
 Poker Streams | |
|
Contact Users: 585 Active, 1 Logged in - Time: 00:00
