he is a fish
opinions?

I guess I have to stove this

Probably call. You're never worse than a flip here, and sometimes he might show up with a gutshot.

Oh and didn't notice the dead money, so yeah call for sure.

Interesting for hand discussion perhaps. I'd say call vs fish since he could be showing any two cards here but would like to see some numbers on this as well.
35/65 (or somewhere around that) against AT at worst imo. Vs all other hands he could have + your money invested my feel is this should be a +EV call.

/edit 60/40 on AT so ~flip at worst.

Board: Ad 8s Td
Dead:

equity win tie pots won pots tied
Hand 0: 43.444% 42.69% 00.76% 21976 389.00 { TT, 88, ATs, A8s, KdQd, QdJd, J9s, T8s, 97s, 6d5d, ATo, A8o, J9o, T8o, 97o }
Hand 1: 56.556% 55.80% 00.76% 28726 389.00 { 9d8d }


Long as he can have 79 or J9 in his range like most fish do I say it's a call

this is a call if he shows you AT. a very close one, but a call nonetheless. if you give him a range of sets+at+a8 then I guess its a fold but that's not a particularly likely range ;p