SemPeR   Canada. Feb 08 2011 14:34. Posts 2288
For the 1.5 girls on this forum...
1
The M Show   Canada. Feb 08 2011 17:15. Posts 278
hahahahaha
1
aseq   Netherlands. Feb 08 2011 17:41. Posts 894
Agree with Steal City, it's pretty bad there's only 2 options, if you don't trust the other person whatsoever there's nothing you can do. You should at least be able to countersteal or something.
I think you would have to watch the whole episode for this kind of show
This is just game theory.
If you steal, you either win all of it or none of it
If you split, you either win half of it or none of it
Therefore, steal is the dominant strategy because you do not know what your opponent will choose.
The problem with always stealing 100% is that you don't know with what probability the other person will steal. (I think your answer assumes the other player will split or steal 50% of the time). And remember (to other ppl in the thread), the goal of the game is to maximize your own game value. The tilt of having the other guy potentially exploiting your play should not be considered in the calculations.
Anyway I think player X can make the other player indifferent from the strategy of "Always Split" or "Always Steal" by stealing 66% of the time and splitting 33% of the time. This is favorable to always steal because it avoids the situation where both players always steal and everybody loses. Although it loses game value to the scenario where both players split (.5) vs (.33), it guarantees that you get some value out of the game.
edit: assuming this is correct(not sure if it is), a fun step after it is to announce your strategy...explain that both players can increase game value by always splitting. deviate from the basic strategy by splitting or stealing if you feel you have the metagame edge.
problem is humans are deceptive and you can't read minds. Therefore, you must choose steal because you can't infer with certainty your opponent's thought process.
GG
Last edit: 08/02/2011 20:39
1
thumbz555   United States. Feb 08 2011 20:49. Posts 3281
I click buttons.
1
Webjoker   Netherlands. Feb 08 2011 21:58. Posts 435
1
XoXthajmanXoX   United States. Feb 09 2011 00:01. Posts 834
SERIOUSLY!
1
Jas0n   United States. Feb 09 2011 00:16. Posts 1866
1
SugoGosu   Korea (South). Feb 09 2011 01:04. Posts 1793
rofl these captchas are great.
Say this outloud! Why was six afraid of seven?......Because Seven Eight Nine