Is this wrong? - Page 2

On March 25 2011 17:43 LemOn[5thF] wrote: Show nested quote + On March 25 2011 17:41 hiems wrote: This is a silly question because right and wrong in this situation is inherently arbitrary. You need to clarify that before anyone can answer the question. All right, if you had a hot sister and were presented with the exact same scenario, would know 100% nobody will ever find out and that there wouldn't be any negative emotions in the future, and you can only gain (clearly gains>losses so you'd be maximizing utility) would you do her?

I have never had a sister so I can't answer that question.

And fwiw someone's response to your question has nothing to do with whether it's right or wrong.

how so?

:O i dont believe in morals so i answer 'dont know'

However this is pretty dam gross, i guess some people are born with less pheramones than others?

On March 25 2011 17:34 tooker wrote: would finding your sister attractive also be "gross"?

Describe what you mean by attractive?
Does this mean you objectively think your sister happens to be a good looking woman? Then no, I think thats pretty standard.
Does this mean you are sexually attracted to her? Yeah, lol, thats gross dude.

For full disclosure I have a sister and she is considerably younger than me. (9 years apart) Perhaps the age difference has something to do with why I find it gross? I dont know, I just think its pretty sick.

On March 25 2011 15:29 atateconst wrote: Having sex with your sister is gross IMO. Its not a matter of morals to me, I'm an athiest, but that doesnt mean I cant rationally think its gross to have sex with your sister or your mother or your daughter. Gross.

because atheists don't have morals obviously... or was the atheism part just a random fun fact about you that wasn't at all related to your response?

On March 25 2011 19:49 DaTruf wrote: Show nested quote + On March 25 2011 15:29 atateconst wrote: Having sex with your sister is gross IMO. Its not a matter of morals to me, I'm an athiest, but that doesnt mean I cant rationally think its gross to have sex with your sister or your mother or your daughter. Gross. because atheists don't have morals obviously... or was the atheism part just a random fun fact about you that wasn't at all related to your response?

I addressed this already.

Many religions implicitly denounce incest on moral grounds. I didnt intend to imply that atheists cant/dont have morals, just pointing out that I'm not required to find it 'wrong', as some people are.
Yeah, it was unnecessary, who fucking cares? I didnt realize it was such a BFD to mention that you're an atheist around here.

just do it lemon

On March 25 2011 19:59 joLin wrote: just do it lemon

Obv Lemon is "Mark".

On March 25 2011 20:00 atateconst wrote: Show nested quote + On March 25 2011 19:59 joLin wrote: just do it lemon Obv Lemon is "Mark".

What if Lemon..... is Julie!

+ Show Spoiler +

just say no to sisters

keeping secrets like that can give you cancer

lol wat in the fuck.

LP: where dudes fuck their sisters.

has a nice ring to it.

On March 26 2011 14:42 YoMeR wrote: lol wat in the fuck. LP: where dudes fuck their sisters. has a nice ring to it.

When are the t-shirts going on sale? I'll take a couple. :biggrin:

I'm surprised they were able to get that study by ethics haha. I guess it was 2001 though.